To choose an ecommerce agency, check three things before anything else: that they are an official partner of your platform, that they can show measured results from stores like yours, and that you will own your store, code and data outright. After that, the right choice comes down to who will actually do the work, how they protect your SEO during a migration and what support looks like after launch. The 12 questions below will help you test all of this in a first call.
This is written for founders, ecommerce managers and heads of digital at growing brands, mainly on Shopify, Shopify Plus or BigCommerce. We are an agency ourselves, so we have tried to make it a fair guide you could use with anyone, including us.
Before you start: know what you are buying
Agencies are hard to compare because they sell different things under the same name. Before you shortlist, write down in a page or less:
- What you need: a new build, a redesign, a migration, ongoing support or a mix.
- Your platform, or whether you need help choosing one.
- Your budget range and any fixed dates, such as a peak trading period you cannot launch into.
- The two or three numbers that would tell you the project worked.
Shopify's own advice on hiring a partner makes the same point: be clear on budget, timeline and expected results so partners can quote accurately. A clear brief also makes weak proposals easier to spot.
The 12 questions
1. Are you an official partner of our platform, and at what level?
Both Shopify and BigCommerce run partner programmes. Shopify's Partner Directory groups partners into four tiers (Select, Plus, Premier and Platinum), which Shopify describes as typically preferred by businesses from small and medium up to global enterprise. BigCommerce's agency programme has its own levels, which its guide to ecommerce agencies names as Certified, Preferred and Elite.
A good answer is specific and checkable: the agency names its status and you can find it in the platform's directory. Tiers are set by each platform against its own criteria. Shopify's partner tiering guide, for example, bases them on the revenue and the number of new merchants a partner brings to Shopify, recalculated each quarter, so a higher tier signals scale rather than a guaranteed fit for a growing brand. Be wary of anyone who blurs the names: being an official Shopify Partner is not the same claim as holding a Plus, Premier or Platinum tier.
2. Can you show measured results from stores like ours?
A good answer includes before and after figures, the time period and how they were measured: conversion rate, average order value, page speed scores or launch time. Ask what else changed in the same period, such as a sale or a new ad budget, because honest agencies will tell you. Vague claims like "doubled sales" with no baseline are worth little.
3. Who will actually do the work?
Many agencies pitch with senior people and deliver with junior staff or subcontractors. A good answer names the roles on your project, says whether any work is outsourced and to whom, and tells you who your day to day contact will be. It is reasonable to ask to meet the lead developer before you sign.
4. How will you protect our SEO during a migration?
If you are moving platform or changing URLs, this is the question that protects your revenue. Google's guidance on site moves recommends mapping every old URL to its new one, using permanent 301 redirects and keeping them for at least a year.
A good answer covers a full crawl and redirect map before launch, preserving page titles, meta descriptions and structured data, testing redirects on staging, and monitoring rankings and Search Console for weeks after go-live. If you are weighing up a move, our ecommerce migration page sets out how we approach it.
5. How do you approach site speed?
A good answer mentions Core Web Vitals, measured on real devices as well as in lab tools, and a plan for keeping apps and third-party tags under control. An agency that only quotes a single PageSpeed score has not told you much.
6. How do you decide between apps and custom code?
Apps are quick and cheap to start, but each one adds cost and can slow the store. Custom code is tailored but needs maintaining. A good answer explains the trade-off for your specific needs and does not default to either.
7. What does support look like after launch?
A good answer covers a warranty or bug fix period, a monthly support or retainer option, response times in writing and how urgent issues are handled out of hours. Ask what happens to a feature request versus a broken checkout.
8. How and how often will you communicate with us?
A good answer sets a rhythm: a named contact, a regular update, a shared project board and an agreed reply time. Ask how they report on hours and budget during the project, not just at the end.
9. Who owns the code, the store and the data?
You should. On Shopify, the store account should be in your name, and agencies should work in it through collaborator accounts, which give a partner access with permissions you choose and can remove, and which cannot hold the administrator role. A good answer confirms that you own the store, the domain, the theme or front end code and all data, and that the contract transfers intellectual property on payment.
10. What does the contract cover, and how do we leave?
A good answer includes a clear scope, how changes are priced, payment milestones linked to delivery, notice periods and a handover process if you part ways: code repositories, credentials and documentation. A long lock-in with no exit terms is a warning sign.
11. How do you test before launch?
A good answer describes a staging environment, test orders through every payment method, checks across devices and browsers, and a launch checklist with a rollback plan. Ask who signs off and when launches are scheduled. Avoiding your busiest hours is a sign of experience.
12. Can we speak to a current client?
A good answer is yes, ideally someone who has worked with them for more than a year. Ask the reference what went wrong and how the agency handled it. Every project has problems, so the useful part is how they were handled.
Quick reference: what to listen for
| Topic | Good sign | Red flag |
|---|---|---|
| Partnership | Named status you can verify in the platform directory | Vague or inflated partner claims |
| Results | Before and after figures with dates and method | Big claims, no baselines |
| Team | Named roles, outsourcing disclosed | "Our team" with no detail |
| SEO on migration | Full redirect map, staging tests, post-launch monitoring | "Redirects are handled automatically" |
| Speed | Core Web Vitals on real devices, tag and app discipline | One PageSpeed score as proof |
| Support | Written response times, warranty period | "Just email us" |
| Communication | Named contact, regular updates, budget tracking | Updates only when you chase |
| Ownership | Store, code, domain and data in your name | Agency holds the account or code |
| Contract | Clear scope, change pricing, exit and handover terms | Lock-in with no exit route |
| Testing | Staging, test orders, rollback plan | Testing on the live store |
| References | Long-standing clients happy to talk | No references available |
Other red flags
- A fixed price before they understand your store. A credible quote needs a discovery stage or at least a proper look at your current setup.
- Guaranteed rankings or revenue. Nobody controls Google or your market. Measured past results are useful; promises are not.
- Pressure to move platform. A good agency will sometimes tell you to stay where you are.
- No questions about your business. If the first call is all about them, the project will be too.
Comparing proposals fairly
Once you have two or three proposals, compare them on the same basis: scope, team, timeline, total cost including apps and support, and what happens after launch. The cheapest build can become the most expensive if it needs rework within a year. If proposals differ widely in price, ask each agency what the others have included that they have not.
FAQs
Should I choose a specialist or a generalist agency?
For a growing store, a specialist in your platform is usually the safer choice, because they will know its limits and workarounds. A generalist may suit you if ecommerce is a small part of a wider digital project.
Does a higher partner tier mean a better agency?
Not necessarily. Tiers are partly based on how much business an agency brings to the platform. They are a useful signal of scale, but results, team and fit matter more for most growing brands.
Does it matter if the agency is in the UK?
A UK agency shares your time zone, understands UK consumer law and VAT, and can meet in person. That is useful, but not essential if communication and support terms are strong.
How long should choosing an agency take?
Allow a few weeks for briefing, calls, proposals and references. Rushing the choice to hit a launch date often costs more time later.
How Superior can help
We are a London agency and an official Shopify Partner and BigCommerce Partner, and we are happy to be asked all 12 questions. Our results include Loci's conversion rate rising from 1.75% to 2.2% after a UX audit, and you can see more in our work or start with a free starter audit.